Executive Summary

Enterprise organizations are increasingly faced with the challenge of modernizing their legacy monolithic systems. These systems, which are often mainframe-based and written in COBOL or similar technologies, have served as the backbone of operations for decades. However, in the era of digital transformation, these monolithic systems become impediments to progress and sources of risk.

The modernization of enterprise systems is not merely a technical concern, but a strategic necessity. Legacy monolithic architectures are deeply entrenched in critical business functions, making them difficult to replace or overhaul without disrupting operations. In the worst case, continuity of the systems is increasingly expensive and hard to guarantee. In the better case, they are still a sustainable solution but get in the way of meeting the growing demands for faster time-to-market, enhanced customer experiences, and modern cost optimization. CIOs must balance the pressure to transform legacy systems with the need to mitigate risks, preserve business continuity, and secure stakeholder buy-in.

As organizations embark on modernization, they face numerous challenges, including technical debt, skill shortages, and the complexity of integrating legacy systems with modern technologies. However, there are strategies which can help to mitigate and overcome these challenges. The difficulties and risks of heavily outdated technology only grow with time, and years of quick-fix workarounds can ultimately add complexity to the modernization work ahead.

While safeguarding core business processes, enterprises can take the opportunity to re-imagine their IT infrastructure and position themselves for long-term success. Modernization also helps organizations become better equipped to adapt to regulatory changes, protect data security, and create innovative products and services. For CIOs, the journey from mainframe to digital transformation represents the challenge of driving meaningful change.

This green paper explores the strategies and considerations for modernizing these enterprise monoliths, outlines a comprehensive roadmap that addresses both the technical and organizational dimensions of modernization, and provides actionable insights for CIOs navigating this complex journey.

Introduction

Mainframe systems and COBOL applications remain critical to enterprise operations in industries such as finance, retail, healthcare, and government. The stability of these systems are direct determinants of mission-critical processes. Despite the strengths and reliability these systems may have represented in the past, they increasingly struggle to meet the demands of modern business conditions characterized by rapid technological change, deprecation of older technologies, dynamic market conditions, and evolving customer expectations.

The growing demands for real-time data processing, seamless integration with cloud platforms, and adaptability to emerging technologies test the limits of older systems. Enterprises relying on legacy systems face difficulties in scaling operations and responding to market changes. The potential of new, innovative solutions can be compromised by realities of legacy data and a lack of cohesion in products. Core systems go from being positive assets to posing strategic and operational challenges.

Modernizing systems is not just an IT initiative; it is a necessity for survival in an era where agility and customer-centricity are paramount. Successful modernization can unlock significant business value by enhancing operational efficiency, fostering innovation, and creating new revenue streams. In facing the challenges of modernization, it is a chance for CIOs to define the future plan, the identity of technical direction, and to see past the tactical struggles to maintain the legacy environment. Modernizing systems is an opportunity to redefine the organization's technological foundation for long-term competitiveness.

This green paper delves into the critical considerations and actionable strategies that CIOs need to navigate this transformative process effectively.

Why Modernize

The Legacy Burden

Legacy systems, while reliable, often come with inherent drawbacks that hinder an organization's ability to adapt and innovate. Recognizing these limitations is the first step toward effective modernization. Below are some of the most pressing challenges associated with maintaining monolithic systems:

Technical Debt

Legacy systems often carry significant technical debt. The complexity of these monoliths makes enhancements and maintenance costly and time intensive. The success of writing-then-forgetting becomes the overhead of later analysis and discovery.

Skill Shortages

COBOL expertise is dwindling as the workforce ages, posing risks to operational continuity. Onboarding resources and teaching domain knowledge is slowed by the additional need to train in outdated and often mixed code patterns. This can make it harder to teach modern patterns.

Integration Challenges

Legacy systems are not designed to integrate seamlessly with modern cloud-native technologies, APIs, and microservices. When legacy data problems and legacy code form part of integrations, the analysis and solution creation can be as complex as partial or whole rewrites.

High Operational Costs

Mainframe operations consume significant resources, from licensing fees to specialized infrastructure. Catching up to product end of life dates can become an uphill march.

Additional Modernization Drivers

Modernization is not merely a technical endeavor; it is driven by evolving business needs and external pressures. Understanding these drivers helps CIOs frame the importance of modernization in the broader context of enterprise objectives. The key factors include:

Customer Expectations

End-users demand seamless, omnichannel experiences and real-time services, pushing enterprises to modernize.

Agility and Innovation

Modern systems enable faster product development, better data insights, integration of AI/ML, and responsiveness to changing business needs.

End of Life Technologies

Technologies are most helpful when they have mainstream support. Without this, resources become harder to find and products are less well maintained or altogether dropped.

Regulatory Compliance

Modern systems simplify compliance with evolving regulations through better data governance and security. Demands which are reasonable for organizations to meet with modern systems, may be a struggle without modernization.

Strategies, Considerations, Challenges, & Automation

Modernization Strategies

Successful modernization requires a thoughtful approach tailored to the unique challenges and opportunities of each organization. CIOs have a range of strategies to choose from, each offering distinct benefits and trade-offs. These strategies include:

· Rehosting and Re-platforming

By adopting new platforms, enterprises gain access to scalable cloud infrastructure and advanced analytics capabilities without a complete rewrite.
Lift-and-shift approaches move applications from mainframes to other platforms, possibly including cloud or virtualized environments. This method minimizes risks and preserves the status quo while reducing costs. Typical challenges can include files shared between systems, or operating system assumptions which fail to translate easily.

· Refactoring

Refactoring involves rewriting COBOL code to modern languages like Java, .NET Core or Python, enabling integration with microservices and APIs. Judicious planning and sound analysis can identify the best targets for ROI and anticipate harder-to-mitigate risks. Short-term targets should be implemented in a way that will form part of long-term architecture.
Modular modernization allows enterprises to move the needle while containing risk, and to prioritize critical components to ensure impactful delivery.

Replacement

For systems that no longer align with business objectives, complete replacement with modern COTS (Commercial Off-the-Shelf) solutions or custom applications may be the best option.

Architectural Considerations

Modernizing legacy systems involves a rethink of architectural paradigms to provide modern scalability, resilience, and compatibility with emerging technologies. Equally important is the mitigation of risk that may be enabled by iterative modernization. Key architectural considerations include:

Microservices Adoption

Breaking the monolith into microservices is a modern trend in development which can aid scalability and constrain complexity inside codebases. In modernization, it also serves as a template for making atomic moves from old to new.

APIs and Integration Layers

APIs are the modern standard for integration between systems, taking the place of file movements, elaborate batch architectures and other plumbing layers. APIs can enable piecemeal modernization and can also open the way to using off the shelf products to form parts of the future solution.

Event-Driven Architectures & Cloud-Native

Leveraging event-driven architectures for real-time data processing may initially seem complex or unsuitable for some legacy systems. However, these architectures can provide transformative solutions to specific legacy data challenges, enabling greater responsiveness and scalability. Transitioning to cloud-native environments can also present obstacles in the legacy landscape but offers significant benefits, including simplified operations, enhanced flexibility, and improved innovation potential.

Challenges in Modernization

Despite the clear benefits, modernization efforts are often fraught with challenges. Acknowledging and addressing these challenges upfront can help CIOs mitigate risks and set realistic expectations. Common obstacles include:

Cultural Resistance

Employees accustomed to legacy systems may resist change, emphasizing the need for change management strategies. There is a mental shift that must occur from nurturing a familiar system to dispassionately planning its replacement. Teams must understand they are a part of the systems’ future.

Data Migration Risk

Migrating data from mainframes or outdated schemas often becomes a standalone initiative requiring meticulous planning and robust risk mitigation strategies. Identifying specific areas for modernization enables organizations to build a future-ready data architecture while maintaining the continuity of critical legacy processes upstream and downstream.

Downtime Concerns

Integrating legacy systems with modern architectures often necessitates hybrid deployment strategies, where rollbacks can be complex and challenging to execute. In environments with intricate legacy setups and tightly scheduled overnight processes, it is essential to thoroughly understand existing workflows to effectively plan and execute releases without disruption.

Cost and ROI

Significant upfront investments demand clear ROI projections and a focus on long-term value realization. Leadership must recognize when IT pain points escalate into critical business risks that lack quick fixes. Additionally, organizations must avoid the temptation to prioritize simpler, low-impact initiatives at the expense of sustaining IT health and long-term viability.

The Role of Automation

Automation is crucial for accelerating and de-risking the modernization journey. In modern software systems, automated testing acts as a safeguard against errors during future refactoring and development. Modernization, being one of the most intensive forms of refactoring, significantly benefits from these techniques. While implementing automation at scale is challenging, it can be introduced progressively, aligning with the substantial testing requirements of modernization efforts.

By adopting automation tools, enterprises can simplify complex processes, minimize human error, and maintain consistency across critical areas, ultimately driving efficiency and reliability. Areas in which to consider automation include:

Automated Code Analysis

Tools that analyze codebases can complement human analysis efforts and may provide aggregate insights which help to steer modernization efforts. EQengineered has developed internal tooling to help inform analysis in areas such as references between complex concerns and data usage.

DevOps Enablement

Automation of CI/CD pipelines ensures faster, more reliable deployments and reduces manual intervention. Errors can be traced to specific deployment versions with more certainty.

Modernization Roadmap for CIOs

Modernization is a journey that requires clear planning and execution. CIOs must take a structured approach to ensure alignment with business goals and minimize disruptions. Key steps in the roadmap include:

1. Define Objectives

Align modernization goals with business objectives, such as improving agility, reducing costs, or enhancing customer experiences.

2. Engage Stakeholders

Work closely with business leaders, IT teams, and external partners to achieve alignment and secure stakeholder buy-in. In highly complex systems, it is common for users, operational staff, and diverse technical contributors to possess critical knowledge that is not fully shared across teams. Effective collaboration ensures these fragmented insights are integrated, enabling a comprehensive understanding and smoother execution of modernization efforts.

3. Assess Current Systems

Perform a comprehensive inventory and analysis of existing systems, focusing on identifying critical components and dependencies. A detailed approach is essential—while some issues may surface only during implementation, the overall feasibility and strategic direction must be clearly understood upfront to ensure a successful modernization effort.

4. Develop a Modernization Plan

Prioritize initiatives by assessing their business impact, technical feasibility, and associated risks. Recognize that maintainability will be an ongoing process, requiring organizations to navigate various hybrid phases. To ensure success, avoid the pitfalls of intermittent progress that erode momentum and undermine confidence in the team’s understanding and capabilities.

5. Adopt Agile Practices

Implement agile methodologies to deliver incremental value and respond effectively to evolving requirements. Large-scale modernization efforts are complex and require consistent project management practices that provide visibility for business stakeholders and foster shared accountability across teams. Recognizing that each modernization journey is unique, integrating continuous improvement practices ensures ongoing identification of efficiency opportunities.

6. Invest in Talent

Focus on upskilling existing teams to build confidence in modern technologies while maintaining and adapting legacy systems during transition phases. Engage with partners who not only bring expertise in modern tools and practices but also possess a deep understanding of the intricacies and challenges inherent to legacy environments.

Case Studies: Real Scenario Examples

Several real-world examples of the strategies outlined in this paper that have been employed by EQengineered with its clients include:

Code Discovery, Analysis and Roadmap (DAR)

EQengineered has performed an in-depth discovery and assessment of client COBOL applications, identifying critical business functions and pinpointing key modernization opportunities. This process includes designing a forward-looking data schema that supports scalability and aligns with the organization’s growth objectives. The outcome of the DAR phase is a comprehensive roadmap, forming the foundation for the Execution phase—the "E" in EQengineered's DARE methodology).

Practical Application Rewrites and Modular Modernization

EQengineered has partnered with clients to rewrite applications, either partially or entirely, while incorporating new technologies and architectural patterns to minimize risk. By leveraging APIs, standardized navigational frameworks, Single Sign-On (SSO), and other techniques, EQengineered ensures a modular modernization approach. This practical release strategy prevents projects from becoming theoretical exercises, ensuring deliverables are functional, utilized, and aligned with business goals.

Schema Analysis and Data Migration

EQengineered has conducted comprehensive schema analyses for clients, uncovering core limitations through in-depth discovery sessions and stakeholder engagement. From these insights, EQengineered has designed forward-looking schemas tailored to meet future business needs. Additionally, the team has successfully managed and directly executed large-scale data migrations, transitioning from legacy systems and schemas to modernized architectures with precision and minimal disruption.

Re-platforming and Rehosting

EQengineered has partnered with clients to prioritize initiatives and lead teams in migrating core products to entirely new platforms. This process often involves rewriting components across the front-end, back-end, and data layers. The result is a streamlined architectural and operational environment with a clear roadmap for achieving cohesion across products.

Agile Adoption in Collaboration with Client Teams

EQengineered has successfully introduced and refined Agile delivery practices, including PMO frameworks and reporting standards. This has enhanced visibility into clients’ maintenance, modernization, and development activities, enabling them to manage multi-year modernization programs with confidence while preparing their teams to independently sustain and evolve future platforms.

Multiple Languages and Layers

EQengineered brings expertise across modern languages like C#, Java, and Python, while also working extensively with legacy technologies such as COBOL. We have guided clients in transitioning from legacy JavaScript to Angular and React, as well as from older Angular versions to modern Angular frameworks. Additionally, we have modernized integration layers involving C and Tuxedo, transitioned pre-Core .NET to modern architectures, moved server-side rendering to modern frameworks, and facilitated migrations from outdated Java containers to contemporary ones. These strategies enable a controlled and iterative approach to modernizing complex codebases.

Conclusion

Modernizing enterprise monoliths is a transformative endeavor requiring a clear strategic vision, detailed planning, and a relentless focus on achieving measurable business outcomes. By employing the right mix of strategies, technologies, and skilled talent, CIOs have the opportunity to drive digital transformation that positions their organizations for long-term success in an increasingly competitive market.

To navigate this journey effectively, partnering with experienced modernization experts like EQengineered ensures access to deep expertise in software engineering, data engineering, and agile delivery practices. Together, we can reimagine and modernize the legacy systems that serve as the backbone of your organization’s operations and achievements.

Modernization is not a one-size-fits-all initiative. It demands a tailored approach that aligns with the unique objectives and priorities of each organization. With a commitment to innovation and a well-structured strategy, CIOs can overcome the challenges of legacy systems and establish a scalable, resilient foundation for sustained growth and competitive advantage in the digital era.

Authors

Mark Hewitt, President & CEO

Mark is a driven leader that thinks strategically and isn’t afraid to roll up his sleeves and get to work. He believes collaboration, communication, and unwavering ethics are the cornerstones of building and evolving leading teams. Prior to joining EQengineered, Mark worked in various management and sales leadership capacities at companies including Forrester Research, Collaborative Consulting, Cantina Consulting and Molecular | Isobar.

Mark is a graduate of the United States Military Academy and served in the US Army.

Julian Flaks– Chief Technology Officer

Julian is a relentless problem solver and hoarder of full stack expertise. Having thrown himself headlong into Internet technology when best practices had barely begun to emerge, Julian is happiest putting his experience to use unlocking business value.

Julian holds a Bachelor’s of Laws from The University of Wolverhampton, England and a Master of Science in Software Engineering from The University of Westminster.

EQengineered's 2025 Consulting Green Paper